JOURNAL OF COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
April 18, 1995

Regular City Commission Meeting Mayor Morris Presiding

CALL TO ORDER: 7:00 PM

ROLL CALL: City Commissioners present: Gayle Morris, Joan Bennett, Bob Deming, Vicki Everson and John Gilbert. Also present were the City Manager, City Attorney, Directors of Community Development, Public Works, Park & Recreation, Fairgrounds, Planning, Fire Chief, Police Chief, Acting Finance Director, and the City Clerk.

PROCLAMATION: Mayor Morris read a proclamation declaring April, Fair Housing Month.

OLD BUSINESS

1.
ORDINANCE 2683, TITLE 2 REVISIONS PERTAINING TO THE LOAN ADVISORY BOARD AND THE PARKING COMMISSION.

The City Commission, at their regular meeting held March 21, 1995, directed Staff to prepare the following modifications to the Parking Commission and the Loan Advisory Board. Ordinance 2683 was prepared to incorporate those changes.

Loan Advisory Board: The City Commission noted that because the City did not have any economic development revolving funds to loan, that the Loan Advisory Board be changed from a formal board to an ad hoc board. The Commission also indicated that the function of the Loan Advisory Board was duplicated through High Plains Development, the Business Improvement District and several other entities in Great Falls.

Parking Commission: The Business Improvement District requested formal representation on the Parking Commission. It was recommended that a sixth, ex-officio, member be added to the composition of the Parking Commission to be appointed by the Business Improvement District.

Commissioner Gilbert moved, seconded by Commissioner Deming, that the City Commission adopt Ordinance 2683.

Motion carried 5-0.

2.
CONSOLIDATED PLAN INCLUDING USE OF 1995/96 CDBG AND HOME FUNDS.

The Consolidated Plan is a new comprehensive five-year planning strategy required by the U.S. Department of Housing & Urban Development. The use of the 1995/96 CDBG and HOME funds is included in the annual action plan portion of the Consolidated Plan. On April 4, 1995, the City Commission held a public hearing to encourage citizen comment regarding the consolidated plan and the funding recommendations for the 1995/96 CDBG program. Based on citizen comment, further expansion of the narrative portion of the Consolidated Plan in the areas of fair housing and homelessness is continuing.

Commissioner Everson moved, seconded by Commissioner Deming, that the City Commission adopt the five-year Consolidated Plan including the Annual Action Plan for use of the 1995/96 Community Development Block Grant and HOME Grant amended as follows:

  1. ..that $16,000 of the $47,205 allocation to the Park and Recreation Stump Removal Program be used to fund diseased elm tree removal and that $31,205 be used for stump removal. That we authorize $33,950 of the 1994/95 Park & Recreation CDBG allocation to be used for diseased tree removal. The City Commission directs Staff to remove 100% of the known diseased trees and stumps in each census track before moving to another census track;
  2. ..that regarding the two recommendations for the YWCA to rehabilitate St. Gerards' for transitional housing; the City Commission directs Staff to place a lien upon the property for the total amount of the grants which equals $92,500. If the building is used for purposes other than transitional housing within five years from the date of this grant, the lien will become payable to the City of Great Falls. If the building remains transitional housing after five years from the time of this grant, the lien will be removed from the property title;
  3. ..the City Commission is aware that the Young Parents Education Center, which is currently housed at the Largent School, may move to Skyline School. If that move occurs, the City Commission directs that the Young Parents Education Center allocation be transferred to the Mobility Impaired project;
  4. ..that $50,000 be taken from the HOME allocation to the Housing Authority and be transferred to the Mobility Impaired project;
  5. ..that a contingency be placed on the HANDS program allocation in that the money is to go toward eliminating the waiting list described in their application.

The City Commission authorizes that the amended 1995/96 Action Plan and HOME plan be submitted to HUD.

Commissioner Gilbert stated that even though the YWCA is a tenant of St. Vincent DePaul, the City Commission is requiring the YWCA to pledge the landlord's property for a period of five years. Mr. Gilbert stated that the YWCA's proposal is to remodel a building that they do not own for transitional housing. Although the Commission concurs with the need for transitional housing, they wanted to better secure the CDBG funds to be used in the remodeling project. Commissioner Gilbert also stated he was concerned that the transitional housing program described by the YWCA in that it does not include displaced men and children. Rather, the program involves only displaced women and children. He reminded the YWCA that the program needs to address both situations and not just focus on women in need.

Commissioner Bennett stated that because of her involvement with HANDS, she would abstain due to a potential conflict of interest.

Motion carried 4-0-1 (Commissioner Bennett abstaining).

NEW BUSINESS

ORDINANCES/RESOLUTIONS

3.
ORDINANCE 2672, 2674, 2675, TITLE 5 (PERTAINING TO SPECIAL LICENSES AND PREMISE PERMITS) RECODIFICATION.

For the past two years, City Staff, in conjunction with a consultant, researched a more equitable system for issuing business licenses. Some Great Falls businesses have been paying license fees, but many have been exempt per State law. The primary reason for the exemption was based on regulatory authority of State agencies versus a local government.

The purpose for City involvement in licensing businesses involves creating a register of all businesses in Great Falls and providing safety and health inspections of the premises. The City is not involved in regulation of business activity. Because of this, Staff proposes to eliminate any concept of such regulation from the City Code book and focus on premise permits to cover the cost of health, safety and welfare inspections and other services.

In conjunction with proposing a new system for issuing business licenses and permits, many ordinances duplicated by Montana State Law are proposed to be deleted with these revisions.

Commissioner Gilbert moved that the City Commission reject Ordinances 2672, 2674 and 2675 on first reading.

The motion died for lack of a second.

Commissioner Deming stated he would prefer tabling action on the ordinances rather than rejecting them. Commissioner Gilbert stated that rejecting the ordinances infers that the City Commission has doubts about the way in which the ordinances were written and that the ordinances need to be rewritten before they come back to the Commission. He added that tabling infers that the Commission will revisit the same issues again.

Commissioner Everson stated she preferred tabling action on the ordinances because tabling establishes a foundation to base further discussions. She added that through Commission direction, the ordinances could be amended. Commissioner Everson stated she would prefer Staff amend the ordinances proposed rather than to start all over again. She suggested that a sub-committee made up of a representative from the City Commission and members of the community to meet and review the proposals to change the business license system in Great Falls.

Commissioner Deming stated that if he were voting on the new fee schedule for business licenses, he would approve it. However, he stated the language in the proposed ordinances was too harsh. He directed Staff to remove the harsh language and to bring it back before the City Commission.

Commissioner Gilbert moved, seconded by Commissioner Everson, City Commission table Ordinances 2672, 2674 and 2675.

Commissioners Deming and Bennett stated they concurred with the concept of the proposed ordinances. However, suggested that the ordinances be revised to include more thorough definitions, time tables for conflict resolutions, and to involve the community in the final proposal.

Commissioner Gilbert suggested that the people most affected by the new ordinances should be involved with writing them.

Commissioner Everson stated she did not agree with the language of 5.01.060, pertaining to renewal notices. She also requested a copy of the Anderson & Associates study conducted regarding this title.

Motion carried 5-0.

4.
ORDINANCE 2686, REZONE 5.24 ACRES IN NE3 SEC. 5, T20N, R4E.

If approved on final reading, Ordinance 2686 will rezone 5.24 acres located in the NE3 Section 5, T20N, R4E, from its present Suburban Residence Use District to "C" Residence Use District. The property is located along the north side of the Northeast Bypass between Giant Springs Access Road and 38th Street North. The purpose of the rezoning is to accommodate a planned condominium project consisting of approximately 30 residential units.

Commissioner Bennett moved, seconded by Commissioner Deming, that the City Commission accept Ordinance 2686 on first reading and set 7:00 p.m., May 16, 1995, as the date for the public hearing and final reading.

Motion carried 5-0.

5.
RESOLUTION 8721, ANNEXING RIVERVIEW RETAIL SUBDIVISION AND APPROVING MINOR PLAT AND ANNEXATION AGREEMENT.

Sletten Ranch Company, the property owner, and Civic Land Consultants, Inc., a Colorado engineering firm, submitted an application to annex a single 19.5 acre lot located long the north side of Smelter Avenue and the west side of Eighth Street Northeast. A 130,000 square foot retail store is proposed to be erected on the site with room for a potential 60,000 square foot building expansion.

Commissioner Gilbert moved, seconded by Commissioner Bennett, that the City Commission approve the minor plat of Riverview Retail Subdivision, the accompanying Annexation Agreement and adopt Resolution 8721 subject to the developer and owner executing the Agreement and satisfying the fees and charges enumerated therein.

Tom Crane, 3018 9th Avenue South, stated he did not support the annexation to facilitate the building of Walmart.

Motion carried 5-0.

CONSENT AGENDA
6.
Minutes, April 4, 1995 regular Commission meeting.
7.
Claims over $500.
8.
Contracts List.
9.
User Permit list.
10.
Contract Bid Award, Water Treatment Plant Baffles, Gates, Structural Repairs (OF 1030.1). Award contract to Sletten Construction, Inc., in the amount of $592,940.00.
11.
Postpone Bid Award, Large Scale Rotary Mower. Postpone bid award for the second time, until June 30, 1995, for a new 1995 large scale rotary mower. This would allow Staff additional time to complete potential mowing privatization research. The privatization research includes receiving and analyzing RFP's to contract for mowing services of designated City parks.
12.
Postpone Bid Award, 1995 Tandem Axle Truck with Refuse Packer. Postpone bid award to allow Staff additional time to analyze bids.
13.
Contract Bid Award, 1995 Sewer Rehabilitation Program, Phase III (OF 1083). Award contract to Planned & Engineered Construction (PEC) of Helena, in the amount of $767,290.
14.
Change Order #1, Civic Center Electrical Upgrade, (OF 1057). Change Order in the amount of $2,390 for an additional 100-amp service to the theater stage area for sound equipment.
15.
Bid Award, Four (4) Cardiac Monitor Defibrillators. Award bid to Physio-Control Corporation for the purchase of four (4) Lifepak 300 defibrillators and assorted training equipment and expendable materials needed to start the EMT D program.
16.
Bid Award, New Breathing Air Compressor. Award bid to Midwest Industries for the purchase of one (1) EAGLE Model #BAP 15GH3 compressor and miscellaneous replacement parts for the amount of $17,310.45.
17.
Final Claim, Fire Station and Police Department Re-roof Project (OF 1098). Final claim for Missoula Sheet Metal in the amount of $17,830.93 and $106.98 to the Department of Revenue, Miscellaneous Tax Division.
18.
Easement, Montana Power Company, through a portion of T20N, R4E, Section 5 (38th Street Compost site). Easement to Montana Power Company through the 38th Street Compost site and the American Little League complex.
19.
Set Public Hearing, Resolution 8717, Re-levy and Re-assess SID 1271. Sets public hearing for a resolution to re-levy and re-assess SID 1271 for May 2, 1995 at 7:00 p.m.
20.
Memorandum of Understanding, Railroad Crossing and Track Abandonment. In conjunction with construction of the new 10th Street North Connector Bridge, the railroad crossing at 10th Street Northeast (north approach), will require upgrading to meet standards. The crossing upgrade is estimated to cost over $200,000. In order to eliminate the need for this upgrade, it was suggested that the tract be abandoned. The MOU facilitates the abandonment of the track and is conditioned on the Montana Public Service Commission approving it.

Commissioner Everson moved, seconded by Commissioner Deming, that the City Commission accept the Consent Agenda as printed.

Motion carried 5-0.

BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS

21.
APPOINTMENT, POLICE COMMISSION

The term for Kenneth Kleven will expire April 30, 1995. Mr. Kleven served one three-year term and expressed interest in reappointment.

Commissioner Deming moved, seconded by Commissioner Everson, that the City Commission reappoint Kenneth Kleven to the Police Commission for a three year term beginning May 1, 1995 and ending April 30, 1998.

Motion carried 5-0.

CITY MANAGER

22.
JAIL ALTERNATIVES.

Dick Keen, Administrator Pre-Release Center, proposed options to relieve the problems currently experienced due to the cap at the County Jail. He advised the Commission that the Pre-Release Center received a grant from the Montana Board of Crime Control which will fund jail alternatives. However, the Center must now receive a match for the grant. Mr. Keen requested that $28,000 be budgeted in the next fiscal year for the match. Mr. Keen indicated the jail alternatives could include incarceration at the Pre-Release center to home arrest.

Chief Jones stated that the match was proposed in the budget and the City Commission would have the opportunity to review it during the budget process.

CITY COMMISSION

24A.

Commissioner Everson asked Mr. Gliko, City Attorney, to update the City Commission on the status of the litigation involving the zone change on the "St. Thomas Property." Mr. Gliko advised that the judge had not yet made a determination on the case. He stated that the attorneys involved presented their arguments on March 11, 1994.

Commissioner Everson asked if there was anything the City Commission could do that would motivate the judge to rule on the case. Mr. Gliko advised that the Commission could direct him to file a complaint with the Judicial Commission on Standards.

Commissioner Deming moved, seconded by Commissioner Gilbert that a complaint be filed with the Judicial Commission on Standards.

Commissioner Gilbert stated that while the City is at risk filing a complaint regarding the judge prior to the judge making a decision, the City was being denied access to the judicial system. He added that the City is also losing if the development is not completed due to the long time period of this litigation.

Motion carried 5-0.

24B.
Commissioner Gilbert stated he was concerned with this year's Legislature and its discussions regarding the Lewis & Clark Interpretative Center. He added that the largest portion of the discussion revolved around using the Coal Tax Trust to fund the Interpretative Center. He researched the Coal Trust and discovered that over $4 million was invested outside of Montana and in some cases, outside of the United States. He added that Montana's money was being used to help other communities economically, while Montana's economy dwindled.

24C.
The City Commission presented Erl Tufte, Public Works Director, with a gift of appreciation for this work at the City of Great Falls. Mr. Tufte resigned as Public Works Director in order to take another job in Billings, Montana.

PETITIONS AND COMMUNICATIONS

25A.
Clayton Braden, 2708 4th Avenue NW, requested Staff research what could be done to improve the road on 17th Street between 5th and 6th Avenues NW. He suggested that due to the heavy truck traffic and a broken water main, the road deteriorated quickly.

25B.
Bob Meyers, Manager of the Senior Citizens Center, thanked the City Commission for approving a CDBG allocation for the Center.

ADJOURNMENT

There being no further business to come before the Commission, the regular meeting of April 18, 1995, adjourned at 8:15 p.m.


/S/
Gayle Morris, Mayor

/S/
Peggy J. Bourne, City Clerk




1995 Commission Minutes
Commission Minutes listing page